Elementary Schools Are Enemies of Play

Utica Elementary School in Pennsylvania.  Photo credit: fasd.k12.pa.us

Young children have always had to deal with a sharp decrease in their free play time as they transitioned over a couple of years from no school to elementary school, which they attend about seven hours a day.

However, in decades past, schools recognized that children of that age need a lot of play to develop appropriately. They had ample recess breaks with free play every day during the school day, and they let children leave school behind them every day when they went home.

In recent years, though, elementary schools have become enemies of children’s play. Many are working to eliminate play at school recess and to eat away at the small amount of play time children have at home by assigning more and more homework. Recess: Schools Work to Eliminate Play at School
Numerous schools across the US have eliminated recess entirely or reduced the amount of time to devoted to it. This is true despite the numerous research studies that show that recess actually helps elementary school children learn better in school.

An organization called Rescuing Recess has recently been formed to bring recess back to schools, and it is sponsored by such organizations as the Cartoon Network, the National Parent Teacher Association, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the National Education Association. That’s quite an impressive set of supporters.

A National Parent Teacher Association press release announcing the formation of Rescuing Recess states that 40 percent of American elementary schools have either eliminated or are considering eliminating recess.

In addition, many schools like Palo Alto’s Addison Elementary, are re-engineering recess to take all the fun out of it. For instance, children at Addison can’t touch each other in any way, so playing tag or even high-fiving could result in a suspension.

According to a New York Times article, children at Oakdale School in Connecticut can’t play competitive games, and were prohibited from playing with a ball until parents protested and were able to get a non-competitive, supervised form of kickball instituted twice a week.

Children are still encouraged to be active, according to the principal, and are “free to walk the grounds with the school nurse, or depending on the day, sing in the chorus, play chess or pick up litter.”

Homework: Schools Eat Away at Play at Home
In a previous article on Playborhood.com, Sandra Hofferth notes that 6-12 year-olds spent 25% more time doing homework in 2003 than they did in 1997. That’s on top of increases of 144% for 6-8 year-olds and 9% for 9-12 year-olds between 1981 and 1997. The actual averages in 2003 are just over 30 minutes a day for 6-8 year-olds and just over 50 minutes for 9-12 year-olds.

Despite this trend, no one can point to research that says that homework actually helps elementary school kids perform better academically. No correlation between homework and performance has been found. (See this article for a great overview of the evidence, or lack thereof.) Nada. Zilch.

You may have heard the commonly cited rule of thumb about how much homework is “appropriate” for students – 10 minutes per night per grade, so that a first grader should get 10 minutes per night, a second grader should get 20 minutes per night, and so on.

The person responsible for this rule is Duke University psychology professor Harris Cooper, who is perhaps the most famous academic researcher on the benefits of homework. Ironically, in his popular book on the subject, The Battle Over Homework, he states that there is no evidence that homework improves academic performance for elementary school students. His recommendation for homework every night for elementary school students is based not on research evidence but on his intuition that it helps them develop time management skills. Intuition. He has no evidence. Thanks, but no thanks, Professor Cooper.

We Can Work to Reverse This Trend
So, schools are robbing children of their childhoods. They play less and suffer the effects of this, but according to the research, they get no benefit from playing less. What can we do to fight this trend?

Fortunately, there are many examples of schools and parents fighting back successfully. For instance, Denise Clark Pope of Stanford University’s School of Education has started a movement called “Stressed Out Students” (SOS) that puts reduced homework at the centerpiece of its recommendations. Many schools have recently announced reduced homework policies, citing SOS as their guide. SOS runs an annual conference for principals to show them how to implement their recommendations.

Oak Knoll Elementary School of Menlo Park is surrounded on all sides by some of the most competitive, homework-heavy elementary schools in America, but it has a very well-articulated “reduced homework” policy. Principal David Ackerman has the full support of parents in his community, and Oak Knoll’s test scores indicate that it’s keeping up with its neighbors academically.

In the final analysis, vocal parents get the school policies they want. Addison and Oak Knoll, two schools within a couple of miles of each other, have taken the very different paths they have on this issue because they’re doing what their parents have requested. So, if you believe your elementary school should have real recess and a no homework or reduced homework policy, you need to fight for these things or move to a school that already has them, as I just did.

Bookmark the permalink of this post.

5 Responses to Elementary Schools Are Enemies of Play

  1. LINDAG says:

    Your comments about Addison elememtary seem to be off base. Our daughters go to Addison and I often volunteer at recess…the kids may play games that involve touching like tag…as long as its on the grass. High Fiving is allowed, I have even seen teachers give high fives. Kids are often playing touch football during recess as well.

    Have you ever spoken with the addison princiapl in depth? When a parent asked him about their no touch policy, at the start of the 2008 school year, he summed it up as “we do not tolerate hitting”

  2. Mike Lanza says:

    A good friend who has a fifth grader at Addison told me that info about high-fiving and the “no touch” policy. I guess there’s a difference of interpretation out there.

  3. nrnnyc says:

    I live in NYC and send my kids to private school for a bunch of reasons – small class size, more resources, etc. But another big part of our decision was recess and PE. Our local public school only has PE once a week and won’t go outside at all if the temperature is below 45. That means that pretty much all winter, the public school kids are indoors watching movies during recess. Crazy.
    At our (costly) private school, the kids have PE four days a week, and the younger ones also spend 2-3 one day a week in Central Park. To me, that added value makes the tuition costs more palatable. And makes their school experience so much better.
    As for homework…well, we’re working on it!

  4. Chrisie says:

    I was looking for an article like this because my 6 yr old daughter is constantly being written up for touching her classmates. I know that touching is part of social learning so I’m not concerned about it, however, I am concerned about what the teachers are trying to make it. I have found that it is no longer “acceptable” to touch your friends or show affection for friends through innocent touch. I have also found that everything is either turned into sexual harassment or assault. I want her to be free to play without being scrutinized.

  5. simmer says:

    I have a 5 year old in a high performing public school in Brooklyn. She just started mid year, as we recently moved to the neighborhood. My concern is that they are in school from 8:45 – 2:50 with limited recess (once a week),and excessive amounts of homework for a kindergartner. It takes her roughly 30 – 40 minutes each night. They also get home work on weekends.

    During the winter break, which was only a week and a half, they sent home 13 pages of homework, 2 books to read, with the added bonus of a book report.
    I ask if she gets to play with any of the new kids in her class. She said we don’t have recess, all we do is work.

    Last night she had a massive melt down while doing homework. I realized she had enough, I told her it was ok to stop the homework. The school had me sign a note stating that I would make sure home work is completed every night. Who do I complain to? Last time I checked, I was the care giver. My child is stressed out at 5. I don’t know what can be done. But this is NOT OK. How can parents stand up for there kids? No one is listening!!!!!!